Hi there
I'd really recommend you have a look around
Heathbrook. It has massive outdoor space, an on site wildlife garden with its own pizza oven and a curriculum that focuses majorly on art, sport, music and outdoor learning, while keeping teaching standards high. In fact, if you look at their year on year results, they have done better than both other schools on your list for a few years running AND it has a recent Ofsted that validates what it's like at the current moment rather than a historic one.
I have two children there and have run the PTA in the past so I may be a bit biased
, but I can tell you that both my bundles LOVE going to school and are thriving. And they're not the only ones. The teachers and head are lovely and very engaged. It's a real community school that prides itself on being welcoming for all, and some families travel from quite far to send their children there because they love the ethos so much. Hope this helps and good luck with your search - I remember that feeling well!!