Post a reply: PLEASE everyone, tweet your MP and ask for a meaningful vote.

Post as a Guest

This question is a means of preventing automated form submissions by spambots.

BBCode is OFF
Smilies are OFF

Topic review


Expand view Topic review: PLEASE everyone, tweet your MP and ask for a meaningful vote.

Re: PLEASE everyone, tweet your MP and ask for a meaningful vote.

by papinian » Tue Mar 21, 2017 8:37 pm

When I said "For the ignorant" I was using the word it is ordinary sense of "not knowing" because clearly there are plenty of posters who weren't aware that using the word Eire in English to refer to Ireland is regarded as offensive by Irish people.

Julian made a typically gracious apology and I don't understand why other posters have to launch off into an argument about it.

I didn't want to get into politics on this site (although this is a rather political thread in any case) but the "agenda or slant" to which I was referring is that decades of usage of the word Eire to refer to the Republic of Ireland by the British right wing press and by some extreme unionists in Northern Ireland, often in anti-Irish (or anti-Éire) articles and commentaries has severely discoloured the word's meaning for Irish people when used in English.

It's also worth noting that there have been 162 uses of "Ireland" in posts on this site and never, before the post on this thread, a post that used the term "Eire". I think that shows just how out of the ordinary the word is in mainstream discourse.

I also want to say that TODAY is a particularly sensitive day for Irish people in London given the hate-filled attacks from some quarters following the death of Martin McGuinness which bring to mind the dark days of the 1980s when we were routinely abused, discriminated against and fitted up by the Met. Only a couple of weeks ago Hollywood actor Gabriel Byrne described how he was the victim of an anti-Irish attack by British soldiers in London during that time.
http://irishpost.co.uk/actor-gabriel-by ... don-irish/

The ignorance displayed by the usual right-wing Tories in Parliament and the media is in sharp contrast to sympathies displayed by the unionist community in Northern Ireland:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-38685158

Re: PLEASE everyone, tweet your MP and ask for a meaningful vote.

by Annabel (admin) » Tue Mar 21, 2017 6:39 pm

Hi Everyone
Please can we keep all the comments friendly and respectful - we are a local community site after all!

I've deleted a couple of posts after this last one, so if anyone believes their post was the only one deleted they're wrong (I deleted three) but I don't want to have to lock this thread.

Thanks all.

Re: PLEASE everyone, tweet your MP and ask for a meaningful vote.

by Denwand » Tue Mar 21, 2017 6:08 pm

papinian wrote:For the ignorant
(!)

The last Irish Constitution Working Group highlighted this problem. They suggested When using the English language, you call it "Ireland". When using the Irish language you call it "Eire".

But someone on Nappyvalley.net using the word "Eire" to refer to the country is as innocent and insignificant as using word "Nippon" to refer to Japan. Actually the Irish constitution gives specific information on what to call the country when speaking English.

But it is not inn any way "offensive" and what exactly do you mean by "slant" or "agenda"?

Do you suspect Julian of being a secret Fenian or a member of the "Continuity IRA" squirrelling away as a fifth columnist preparing the innocent people of SW18 for the coming Nationalists claim to the six counties???

Whatever Pap baby, once more you've given us a laugh at your pompous expense and unjustified rudeness to innocent posters on this forum :lol:

Re: PLEASE everyone, tweet your MP and ask for a meaningful vote.

by papinian » Tue Mar 21, 2017 4:59 pm

For the ignorant, using the term "Eire" when writing in English is like using "Deutschland" to refer to Germany when one is writing in English. First off, it's wrong - if you're writing in English use the English name of the country. Secondly, it's offensive because it implies an agenda or slant.

Of course you'll see the name "Eire" on Irish stamps and in Irish airports, just like in Germany you'll see the name "Deutschland". That's not the point though.

Re: PLEASE everyone, tweet your MP and ask for a meaningful vote.

by windmill26 » Tue Mar 21, 2017 4:47 pm

:?
kettlebellmum wrote:I think Teresa is great and am so pleased she is fulfilling the will of the majority of the UK in pushing ahead with Article 50. I think my 5 year old and 7 year old have a brighter future because of this. Don't think Tusk and Junker have ever done us any favours, just lining their own pension pots and ignoring years of pleas for reform. Good riddance.

Re: PLEASE everyone, tweet your MP and ask for a meaningful vote.

by LP73 » Tue Mar 21, 2017 4:32 pm

GuyD73 I'm appalled at the wording in your post and you've done yourself no good.
The decision has been made to leave and it will happen.

EIRE is not at all offensive and used frequently by the Irish. Just go to the Cork and Dublin airports and you will see signs in there!

Re: PLEASE everyone, tweet your MP and ask for a meaningful vote.

by kettlebellmum » Tue Mar 21, 2017 4:20 pm

I think Teresa is great and am so pleased she is fulfilling the will of the majority of the UK in pushing ahead with Article 50. I think my 5 year old and 7 year old have a brighter future because of this. Don't think Tusk and Junker have ever done us any favours, just lining their own pension pots and ignoring years of pleas for reform. Good riddance.

Re: PLEASE everyone, tweet your MP and ask for a meaningful vote.

by Seb » Tue Mar 21, 2017 3:31 pm

Thats why I asked!

I'm sure their mobile phone business was called Eiretel at one point.

:-)

Re: PLEASE everyone, tweet your MP and ask for a meaningful vote.

by Denwand » Tue Mar 21, 2017 3:17 pm

The use of "Eire" is so offensive....

...The Republic of Ireland still use it on their postage stamps...here's a recent 48 cent stamp.

...better tell them how offensive that is to Irish people... :lol:

Image

Re: PLEASE everyone, tweet your MP and ask for a meaningful vote.

by Seb » Tue Mar 21, 2017 2:22 pm

Why is Eire offensive?

I didn't know either...

Re: PLEASE everyone, tweet your MP and ask for a meaningful vote.

by juliantenniscoach » Tue Mar 21, 2017 2:08 pm

I had no idea Eire was offensive. Apologies to any who were offended.

Re: PLEASE everyone, tweet your MP and ask for a meaningful vote.

by papinian » Tue Mar 21, 2017 1:52 pm

juliantenniscoach wrote:I would suggest the EU would not be able to avoid offering 'quid quo pro' without individual countries such as Eire and Spain breaking rank and accepting on a national basis.
What sort of person says "Eire" in this day and age? It's offensive and unnecessary. If you can't call it Ireland just say Republic of Ireland.

For what it's worth, Ireland has concerns about the large number of British migrants who have moved there because benefit levels are as much as 50% higher. There are very very few Irish migrants in the UK that either have not been here long enough to get permanent residency or are not earning enough to be entitled to a work visa.

Ireland is already experiencing illegal migration from the U.K.: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-38943531

Re: PLEASE everyone, tweet your MP and ask for a meaningful vote.

by juliantenniscoach » Tue Mar 21, 2017 1:30 pm

I'd like to see the UK Govt take the initiative over the EU and declare that all EU citizens currently resident in the UK can have indefinite right to remain here. Even Nigel Farage never said Brexit was about kicking people out. I think it would send a very positive message to the country, our citizens abroad and EU residents here.

In theory it would weaken our negotiating position, but I would suggest the EU would not be able to avoid offering 'quid quo pro' without individual countries such as Eire and Spain breaking rank and accepting on a national basis.

Perhaps one could lobby M.P's, M.E.P's accordingly? Just a thought.

Re: PLEASE everyone, tweet your MP and ask for a meaningful vote.

by Denwand » Tue Mar 21, 2017 1:10 pm

Well Guyd73...really!

I rest my case M'lud as your last two spittle-flecked and swivel-eyed posts perfectly illustrate my point about your puerile outbursts.

You just don't get it do you?

It's not your MESSAGE it's the way you EXPRESS it in childish, insulting and ill-considered invective. All those objecting to your post were Remainers - like myself!

As for comparing yourself to Gina Miller - please take some time out to read her considered,diplomatic,intelligent and inclusive articles - and compare them with your own original "rant".

Finally, your ill-judged and assumptive assertion that i am a malicious troll who writes under the name of Denshort and Denwand...if I was such, you might of thought I wouldn't have picked two names that were *slightly* less obviously connected?

But then again you seem so deluded that you probably think every post on here is written by me!

You'd better stop posting now before you do the Remain cause any more harm...

Re: PLEASE everyone, tweet your MP and ask for a meaningful vote.

by millymoo » Mon Mar 20, 2017 9:53 pm

Yes 48.1% of the country voted to remain in the EU (and I was one of them) but 51.9% voted to leave so we now just have to take a deep breath and get on with it. And while we may think Theresa May has not been given anor electoral mandate to do this, I certainly didn't vote for any if the Eurocrats to dictate what we should be doing either.

Top